1 out of 5 Stars
While I am a huge fan on the Boston Beer Company, I don’t know about this one. This particular beer does not live up to the standards of Samuel Adams, nor does the description as a “Winter Lager” seem to fit.
First, it seemed watered-down. There was no immediate taste. Only after a few seconds did the cinnamon and orange peel come into play, but because the sensation wasn’t immediate, it seemed artificial. I liked the color, but it was a bait-and-switch, betraying a flavor it didn’t have.
And while I can see that cinnamon is a winter flavor, the orange peel taste was out of place. I see orange as more of a late spring/early summer flavor and it didn’t belong in this bottle.
Also, on their Winter Lager page, Samuel Adams states that an additional ingredient in the beer is ginger. I didn’t taste that. Perhaps it contributed to the slow and low sensation of the other flavors.
This beer wasn’t for me, but I remain a fan of Jim Koch and his vision for great tasting beer. For a more representative sample of quality Samuel Adams beer, try the Boston Lager or their seasonals, Summer Ale or Octoberfest.
[...] now, inspiring so many of today’s craft and home brewers. I’m a big fan of Koch, and despite my review of Samuel Adams Winter Lager, I think the Boston Beer Company deserves the top spot on this [...]